We wanted to give you our latest update on the EVA (Ethylenvinylacetat) Foam Puzzle Mats. We were the first blog in the US reporting the recall on EVA foam mats last year and we have received plenty of emails from you all since.
EVA can be produced very cheaply, that’s why it’s so widely used in products ranging from foam mats, bath toys to flip flops and more. Formamide doesn’t smell, is easily absorbed through breathing, skin contact or mouth.
Weekly emails from our readers are consistently asking us if a particular foam mat found online or at a store is SAFE. We also receive many emails from EVA foam puzzle mat manufacturers, resellers and distributors, assuring us that their foam mats are safe AND asking us to update our chart. DON’T STOP READING HERE…..
Why the Formamide Free Statement Is Meaningless
We actually decided NOT TO update our chart, as the whole ‘formamide free’ statement is meaningless. Formamide is usually tested to ONLY a certain level (10mg/kg) and if it passes that level, then test results say ‘PASS’ which translates to ‘formamide free’. At this time, there is NO 100% formamide FREE EVA foam puzzle mat. The government doesn’t regulate Formamide in the US. What also stinks (literally) is that most of the mats are sold in packaging made of toxic PVC!
So please no more emails from manufacturers regarding us updating our chart and stating your mat is “safe” unless it is a mat that does not contain EVA foam!
I am closely following the latest news on Formamide in Foam Puzzle Mats in Europe, and came across an extensive Test Report by OEKO-TEST Magazine in Germany, done in June 2011. OEKO-TEST took a very close look at foam mats and had them thoroughly tested.
Who is OEKO TEST Magazine?
OEKO-TEST is a independent and very reputable consumer watchdog magazine that evaluates and ranks various consumer products for its effect on health & environment. It is similar to Consumer Reports in the US, but with a much stronger emphasis on consumer safety and health.
OEKO-TEST took matters in their own hands and had various foam mats extensively tested. They sent over 15 different foam mats by different manufacturers, also sold in the US, to the lab for testing. Practically all foam mats are produced in China.
The detailed OEKO-TEST Report on Foam Mat Results can be viewed and purchased here.
OEKO-TEST conclusion after reviewing the EVA foam puzzle mat test results:
Here is what Oeko Test concluded after they reviewed the test results:
No foam mat was free of Formamide and/or PAH (Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons), therefore we DO NOT recommend purchasing a foam mat.
PAH (Polycyclic Aromatic Hydrocarbons) which can cause cancer has also been found in most of the foam mats in unacceptable levels unsafe for small children.
Foam Mats that don’t smell, still outgass. Airing the mat doesn’t help. TUEV Rheinland LGA, working with OEKO-TEST testing the foam mats aired the mat over a long period of time.
Children are under a current because the rough (top) part of the puzzle mat can emit an elevated level of electro static current of over 500 volt. The flat surface of the back of the mat is often even higher.
THE TEST CONCLUDED, OEKO-TEST MAGAZINE DOES NOT RECOMMEND ANY FOAM MATS.
How did the Manufacturer react after Oeko Test’s test results?
Most of them said they’re working on a formamide free foam mat.
Can we trust a Formamide Free labeled EVA foam mat? No, you can’t be a 100% sure. OEKO Test said they will test each Foam Mat that’s labeled ‘formamide free’ to make sure it’s truthfully labeled.
NEW French Regulation on Formamide in Foam Puzzle Mats
The new regulations were published in the Official Journal of the French Republic (OJFR) on July 22, 2011. Foam Puzzle mats are still banned in France until at least July 20, 2012, unless the manufacturer, importer or distributor can demonstrate compliance with any one of three conditions below:
“Formamide shouldn’t be used in baby products. Formamide is more harmful than Phthalate.”
– Dr. Hermann Kurse, Toxicologist at the University of Kiel in Germany